1958

Two HOFers drop off after 15 years, Judy Johnson and Pie Traynor, and two others from lack of support, Tommy Henrich and Double Duty Radcliffe.

6 Newt Allen
15 Earl Averill
15 John Beckwith
1 Al Benton
1 Lou Boudreau
7 Tommy Bridges
5 Ray Brown 9th
3 Bill Byrd
6 Roy Cullenbine
15 Kiki Cuyler
3 Leon Day
12 Dizzy Dean 8th
2 Bobby Doerr
12 Wes Ferrell 7th
10 Lefty Gomez
3 Joe Gordon 5th
6 Stan Hack 6th
6 Billy Herman 10th
1 Tommy Holmes
1 Johnny Hopp
8 Bob Johnson
1 Charlie Keller
9 Chuck Klein
6 Ernie Lombardi
14 Dick Lundy
7 Ted Lyons
3 Biz Mackey 3rd
14 Heinie Manush
1 Phil Masi
5 Joe Medwick
1 Pete Reiser
6 Red Ruffing
5 Hilton Smith
1 Snuffy Stirnweiss
1 Birdie Tebbetts
3 Bucky Walters
8 Jud “Boojum” Wilson 4th

Bob’s ballot:

1. Wilson
2. Mackey
3. Hack
4. Herman
5. Dean
6. Gomez
7. Averill
8. Medwick
9. Doerr
10. Cuyler

Terry’s ballot:

1: Jud “Boojum” Wilson
2: Biz Mackey
3: Dizzy Dean
4: Joe Gordon
5: Billy Herman
6: Stan Hack
7: Joe Medwick
8: Ray Brown
9: Lou Boudreau
10: Leon Day

Results:

12 ballots; the results

128 Biz Mackey
119 Jud Wilson
**************
63 Stan Hack
54 Joe Gordon
50 Lou Boudreau
42 Dizzy Dean
38 Ray Brown
35 Billy Herman
34 Wes Ferrell
31 Joe Medwick
20 John Beckwith
11 Bill Byrd
11 Hilton Smith
10 Dick Lundy
10 Ted Lyons
8 Leon Day
8 Chuck Klein
8 Red Ruffing
7 Earl Averill
7 Bobby Doerr
6 Newt Allen
6 Bucky Walters
5 Lefty Gomez
5 Bob Johnson
5 Heinie Manush
4 Kiki Cuyler
3 Charlie Keller
3 Ernie Lombardi
1 Pete Reiser